Pat Boone is a different kind of bad, a bad that is not pure lack of talent like Katy Perry, unbearable awfulness like Foreigner or gross levels of assholery like Axl Rose. No, Pat Boone is a different kind of abomination. I could've gone with any Pat Boone song, but I decided to go with his cover of the hard rock and heavy metal classic "Smoke on the Water" by Deep Purple, because yes, there is a level of blasphemy you didn't think was possible.
Now, before I tear into the abomination of a cover, I want to talk about Pat Boone and why I don't like him. As I said it's not that he lacks talent, and I can understand why people enjoy his music, although it personally makes my skin crawl. No, to really understand I want to take you back to the 1950s, where it was still legal to cater to only white people.
The 50s was the decade in which rock and roll was emerging, and it was mostly coming from the up tempo Chicago blues scene from the late 40s with guys like B. B. King, Muddy Waters and Elmore James. Now, roll in the 1950s with a decent economy and people buying records from some of these black artists. Now marketers got the idea to appeal to conservative parents by selling them watered down versions of "Tutti Frutti", "Long Tall Sally" and "Ain't That a Shame".
That is really why Pat Boone is here, but at the same time it's why he's been popular in the 50s, because conservative America ate it right up. It wasn't as "vulgar" as Elvis, nor as wild as Jerry, but at the same time it was no Bing Crosby, or Frank Sinatra or anyone with a voice and talent.
Which brings me to Pat's 90s release, In a Metal Mood: No More Mr. Nice Guy, where he decided to cover hard rock and heavy metal classics such as "Paradise City", "Crazy Train", "Holy Diver", "Enter Sandman" and of course "No More Mr. Nice Guy" among others, yes this is a thing. Sad thing is he also got metal legends Ronnie James Dio, Ritchie Blackmore and Alice Cooper by his side with this.
Really, all of that would be enough to justify it being an abomination, but nope, this song has to be as wretched as a Buckcherry song, with twice the unbearableness of it all.
But the thing is, I can't actually put my finger on what I find so wretched about this song. I mean, I have found some songs pretty bad that other people enjoy, I have plenty of those coming up, but this is just awful. It's taking a heavy metal song and making it more jazz and gospel like which would be fine, I like Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra and a lot of the other crooners, but this just makes me shudder. I think it's because the entire tone is changed, the original was rough, uncut and almost punk rock sounding, this was because the song was about a fire burning down a casino where the band was originally going to record, so the tone had to be rough and unclean to match. This one just kind of makes it smoother, which does not work for the meaning of the song, it's like taking "The Sound of Silence" and making it an electro-pop tune, some songs work only in specific genres and "Smoke on the Water" works as a hard rock song, not as a lounge jazz tune.
This is one of the worst songs I've ever heard. Yes, alongside some of the other garbage I've done on this blog, alongside "Call Me Maybe" which made me want to pop in the video tape from The Ring, but this made me wish death upon humanity. I don't hate this style of music, but that's because a lot of the music works for that style. This song does not, and quite frankly, Pat Boone is not the best person to even cover a song like "Smoke on the Water" in this style.
I'm the Entity of Darkness and let's forget this ever happened.
No comments:
Post a Comment